Home care for seniors: Is hiring a private individual risky?

Hi, this is Patrick. Hiring a home-care worker directly for a senior is possible, but you become a private individual employer: declarations, the contract, wages, leave and termination of employment are your responsibility. The risk depends on the checks you carry out and how things are organized, not simply on hiring an individual. A mandataire service can help with the formalities without becoming the employer on your behalf.

Do this without delay:

  • Check the home-care worker’s qualifications and references.
  • Ask for proof of professional insurance, including third-party liability insurance.
  • Consider hiring through an accredited agency or a recognized service.
  • Draw up a clear, detailed contract, even when hiring an individual.
  • Find out about the assistance and subsidies available to keep your budget manageable.

To learn more about seniors’ rights and the assistance available, see this practical guide. If you want to understand the differences between home care provided by an individual and by an association, you can also read this detailed comparison.

What are the real risks of choosing an individual?

If you hire someone directly, you must arrange cover for absences and check that the insurance covers the tasks assigned. Cesu simplifies declarations, but it does not remove your employer obligations. With a service provider, the organization employs the worker; nevertheless, ask how they arrange replacements and handle complaints.

Before hiring, check the person’s identity and, with the candidate’s consent, their references, as well as whether their skills match the planned tasks. Specify in writing what is authorized: shopping, keys, accompaniment and managing expenses with receipts. Prescribed care must be provided by qualified healthcare professionals; it should not be confused with help with daily living.

Not having a contract can make the steps involved in a dispute much more complicated. Even so, testimonials show that most individuals often provide reliable, compassionate support.

If a family member is providing the help…

The risk is lower, but the emotional relationship can make it harder to manage things and maintain professional boundaries.

If the help is arranged by an organization…

Check how the organization operates. A service provider is the employer; a mandataire carries out the tasks set out in the mandate, but you remain the employer. An agency or association may offer either arrangement, so its status alone does not tell you what your responsibilities are.

Make the right choice: a three-step process

  1. Step 1: Search and select carefully by checking qualifications, experience and personality.
  2. Step 2: Put the agreement in writing, specifying duties, hours, pay and insurance clauses.
  3. Step 3: Check in regularly and provide feedback to adjust the support and ensure things run smoothly.
CriteriaIndividual hireAgency or association
SafetyDepends on the checks carried out and how things are organizedDepends on the service and how it operates
InsuranceCheck coverage with the insurerAsk for proof of insurance and details of coverage
Quality of supportVariable; depends on the personRegular quality control
CostOften less expensiveMore expensive but more secure
FlexibilityCan be very flexibleSometimes less flexible

Practical example: if you need two hours of help every morning, prepare a sheet listing the tasks, hours, contact person to notify and the plan in case of absence. Check in with the person receiving support after the first few visits. This approach makes it possible to quickly address any mismatch before it becomes a crisis.

FAQ: What you need to know when choosing an individual for home care

  • Q: Can I hire a home-care worker without a written contract? A: For regular help, plan to draw up a written contract. With Cesu, it is required in particular when employment lasts more than four consecutive weeks, regardless of the number of hours. Exceptions for occasional work never exempt you from declaring the employee.
  • Q: What should I check about insurance? A: Tell your insurer what tasks are planned and whether a vehicle will be used. Ask what coverage applies; an independent worker’s professional liability insurance does not replace the obligations associated with employing a salaried worker.
  • Q: What are the signs of an unreliable care worker?
    A: Repeated lateness, failure to follow instructions, or behavior that causes anxiety.
  • Q: Is financial assistance available to pay for home care?
    A: Yes, check with the CAFs and departmental councils, and look into programs such as APA.
  • Q: Who is liable in the event of an accident at home?
    A: The care worker and the private individual employer may both incur civil liability.

For further reading on the actual cost and typical rates, see this explanatory article. You can also find out why weekend home care can be tricky by reading this current-affairs feature.

Thanks so much for reading; best wishes, Patrick

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *